Twenty of our favourite high street stores have gone under the microscope of Webcredible in order to find out how good their usability is. The sample was taken for the first time last year and it found that webcredibly many of the sites really weren’t taking advantage of the potential revenue in the run up to Christmas.
This year they looked at the same 20 high street stores, judged them on 20 different criteria and gave them an overall mark out of 100.
With the results just out, in first place, drum roll please …
With 83/100 points … WHSmith and M&S
This is the second year at the top spot for WHSmith, no points gained but no points lost. On the other hand, M&S snatched an extra 15 points this year to zoom them up into joint first.
M&S re-launched their brand new site just before the report was made and it seems they paid attention to improving their user experience. Well at least someone did! Unfortunately the average score across the sample only increased by 5.5%, the top score isn’t any higher and the lowest score was still 56.
The sites are judged on search results, browsing, product pages, basket and checkout; all things you would expect of an ecommerce site. For simple things like ensuring there is a link to the basket and checkout on every page – all sites should be scoring 5/5, but they weren’t.
Debenhams was the only website out of 20 that changed the colour of the link once you have visited it. Nothing is more annoying than trying to remember what you have already seen. Tut tut to the other nineteen stores who don’t know what their customers want.
How about the guidelines- you know when you click on, for example, women’s department, clothes, tops, evening tops and then when you don’t like the one you clicked on, you go all the way back to the start of the process. How about just taking us back to the evening tops? This is a long term guideline and it is not particularly hard to implement. If not implemented, then it won’t be long before customers start visiting their competitor’s site.
You would also think ‘Proceed to Checkout’ would be a major priority for all the sites but guess what; it was the only guideline with a lower score than last year. Site designers should carefully consider where to place and how to design this button to ensure that customers don’t get lost and drop off at the most crucial stage.
Any website scoring in the 50’s and 60’s, such as Topshop would you believe, really need to up their game. A good ecommerce site is now just as important as the shop itself. If you’re not taking advantage of the online market then your not taking advantage of big money and ultimately you’ll be losing customers to competing stores who know where to put their ‘Buy it Now’ button.